GSF 2011 Winners

Google Science Fair 2011 winners are Lauren Hodge from 13 - 14 years old category, Naomi Shah from 15 - 16 years old, and Shree Bose from 17 - 18 years old. Let's see their projects' summaries:

Lauren Hodge:
Heterocyclic amines, specifically phenylmethylimidazopyridine, are mutagenic and carcinogenic compounds found in grlled chicken.  Although chicken is consumed in large quantities, there is little information on methods of limiting exposure to HCA's.  The objective of this study was to determine whether specific marinade ingredients would inhibit PhIP formation. 
Portions of boneless, skinless chicken breast were marinated in lemon juice, soy sauce, salt water, brown sugar, or olive oil and then grilled om a residential barbeque grill.  Percent weight loss during cooking was recorded and PhIP levels were measured using high pressure liquid chromatograph-mass spectrometer.  The data indicates that some marinades can reduce the PhIP levels.  The brown sugar is a probable inhibitor, the salt water a certain inhibitor; the soy sauce results are inconclusive; the olive oil creates a probable increase in PhIP; and the lemon juice is a certain inhibitor. 
Furthermore, this study showed that PhIP levels increase with cookling time.  Although this study is the first to investigate specific marinade ingredients and their impact on PhIP formation, further studies are needed to better evaluate the specific chemicals important and determining the exact pathways of HCA formation.  Another important project exapansion would be to test the combinations of proven PhIP inhibitor ingredients to produce a carcinogen decreasing marinade.  By developing this marinade, it would have enormous application to the population.  Although we cannot eliminate all carcinogens from our diet, by decreasing amounts we can improve the quality of life.
Naomi Shah

Background: Environmental studies have consistently shown an association between air pollution and exacerbations of illness in people with respiratory diseases such as Asthma (Zhengmin, 2010). Asthma, a chronic disorder in over 160 million people causing one death every twenty seconds, involves the interaction of airflow obstruction, bronchial hyper-responsiveness, and inflammation (WHO, 2005). The global economic burden of asthma exceeds that of tuberculosis and HIV combined. Most medical practitioners currently attribute any degradation in lung health to pathophysiological factors, and routinely suggest steroids and other inhaler treatments to alleviate respiratory disorders. No model currently quantifies the degradation in the PEF rate based on airborne pollutants. Remediation efforts are therefore untargeted.
 
    Goal: The goal of my project is to uniquely quantify the effect of environmental pollutants on the lung function as measured by the Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF) rate. 
    Hypothesis, Experimentation and Model: I hypothesized that the PEF rate of asthmatic subjects varies inversely with the concentration level of four pollutants (independent variables) including Airborne Particulate Matter (PM10), Carbon dioxide (CO2), Carbon Monoxide (CO) and Total Volatile Organic  Compounds (TVOC). The dependent variable, measured in l/min, is the PEF rate of asthmatic subjects.
    In Phase 1, which I started in May 2010, I recruited 103 adult subjects to participate in this study, including 40 control non-asthmatic and 63 asthmatic subjects. I utilized air monitors to record over 4 million air quality readings in each subject's household and work environments. Each subject recorded his or her PEF rate for a period of seven days utilizing standard medical techniques. My methods are scientific and HIPPA compliant.
    In Phase 2, I developed a novel mathematical model and an
interactive online application that quantifies how much of a subject's PEF degradation is caused by the levels of PM10 and TVOC in each subject's environment.
 Results:
  • My hypothesis was partially supported. Based on the Pearson R Correlation coefficient, a strong inverse correlation was inferred between the degradation in PEF rate and the PM10 and TVOC levels, but not between the CO2 and CO concentration levels.
  • Medical practitioners could use my mathematical model as it provides a better estimate for the PEF rate and supports targeted remediation.
Implications
  • Medical: Targeted remediation, less severe asthma symptoms and fewer asthma patients.
  • Environmental: Indoor Air Quality Awareness and Improvement.
  • Political: Clean Air Act, OSHA Regulations (Note that TVOC is not a criteria pollutant in the US Clean Air Act).
  • Economic: Improved workforce productivity, decreased economic burden of asthma and other respiratory disorders.
Future Research:
   There is a saying amongst environmental professionals: "The genetic make-up is like loading a gun. The environmental pollutants represent the trigger!"
    Triggers cause one death every 20 seconds! This project is my sincere hope to increase awareness amongst all stakeholders in order to eliminate the environmental "triggers" that take these innocent lives.
    I am excited about continuing to research respiratory disorders both from a systems and multi-disciplinary perspective. Possible ideas for future research include engineering a smart thermostat that monitors air quality real-time and studying the effect of TVOC on the endothilial lining of our lungs.
    I was also intrigued to learn through background research that there could be some linkage between TVOC and cancer. I have written a letter to the Chairman of the EPA and the U.S. President asking them to allow me to present my findings to them. Perhaps after some due diligence policy makers will agree that our Clean Air Act needs to be amended as it currently does not list TVOC as a criteria pollutant.

Shree Bose